The Best and Worst Ways to Measure Progress in Fitness and Nutrition
Tracking progress in fitness and nutrition can be a game-changer, but only if you’re measuring the right things. In this guide, we’ll break down the most effective ways to measure progress and highlight the common mistakes that can mislead you. Whether you’re focused on fat loss, muscle growth, or overall health, understanding these metrics will ensure you’re on the right track.
Why Measuring Progress Matters
Many people start their fitness journey without a clear way to track progress, leading to frustration and inconsistency. The key to long-term success is using measurable data points that provide an accurate picture of your results.
Cody McBroom, CEO of Tailored Coaching Method, emphasizes the importance of tracking multiple data points instead of relying on just one. By combining body composition, biofeedback, performance metrics, and habits, you can create a holistic view of your fitness journey. Without accurate tracking, it’s easy to assume you’re not making progress when, in reality, you might be improving in key areas that aren’t immediately visible.
When tracking progress, it’s essential to consider long-term trends rather than daily fluctuations. The human body experiences natural weight shifts due to factors such as hydration, glycogen levels, stress, and sleep quality. The goal isn’t perfection but consistency in data collection.
The Worst Ways to Measure Progress
1. Body Fat Measuring Devices (Why They’re Inaccurate)
Devices like bioelectrical impedance scales (BIA), in-body scans, and even some high-tech gym scanners claim to provide accurate body fat percentages. However, research shows these methods can have error rates as high as 8-15%. Factors like hydration, food intake, inflammation, and time of day can drastically alter results, making them unreliable for tracking long-term progress.
A better approach is to look at overall trends rather than fixating on single readings. If you do use these devices, ensure you measure at the same time of day, in the same conditions (hydration level, food intake, etc.), and over an extended period before drawing any conclusions.
To learn more about the different kinds of body fat testing tools and what the science says about their accuracy, check out my blog titled: “Are Body Fat Machines Accurate? [Truth About Body Fat Testing].”
2. The Scale as the Sole Metric
While tracking body weight can be useful, it should never be the only metric you rely on. Weight fluctuates daily due to hydration, glycogen storage, and hormonal changes. Instead of focusing on daily fluctuations, use a weekly average to assess trends over time.
Additionally, weight alone doesn’t differentiate between fat loss and muscle gain. Many people get discouraged when they don’t see the scale drop, even though they may be losing fat while gaining lean muscle. Instead of relying solely on weight, pair it with body measurements, progress photos, and strength improvements.
3. Random Gym Workouts Without Tracking
Going to the gym without a structured plan and failing to track your progress leads to stagnation. Relying on feelings like “Did I sweat enough?” or “Did I feel tired?” won’t help you measure actual improvements. A structured approach ensures you progressively overload your muscles, leading to better results.
A progressive overload plan involves tracking weights, reps, and sets over time. If you’re not consistently increasing resistance, repetitions, or improving movement quality, you may not be progressing. Keeping a training journal or using a fitness app can be invaluable in tracking improvements in the gym.
You can download my app for free and instantly access countless done-for-you training programs that are proven effective, backed by science, and both challenging, as well as exciting! Just head to www.thetailoredtrainer.com.
The Best Ways to Measure Progress
1. Biofeedback: Listening to Your Body
Biofeedback is one of the most overlooked yet essential aspects of progress tracking. It includes:
- Energy Levels – Are you feeling more energized throughout the day?
- Sleep Quality – Are you waking up refreshed?
- Stress and Recovery – Are you handling stress better and recovering well from workouts?
- Digestion – Is your gut health improving? (Using the Bristol Stool Chart can help track consistency.)
- Mood and Motivation – Are you enjoying your workouts and feeling positive about training?
Tracking biofeedback helps identify whether your approach is sustainable and healthy, ensuring long-term success. Many people focus too much on aesthetic changes and ignore internal indicators of well-being. If you’re constantly fatigued, experiencing joint pain, or have poor sleep, those are signs that your training and nutrition may need adjustment.
2. Tracking Performance in the Gym
Strength and endurance improvements are some of the best indicators of progress. Use these metrics to track your performance:
- Progressive Overload – Are you lifting heavier weights or completing more reps over time?
- Conditioning Tests – Are your rowing times, running distances, or aerobic capacity improving?
- Movement Quality – Is your form and technique improving?
- Recovery Rate – Are you recovering faster between sets and workouts?
Using a workout log to track sets, reps, and weights ensures you’re making consistent progress in the gym. Strength increases are one of the best signs of improved body composition, as gaining muscle leads to better metabolic efficiency and fat loss over time.
3. Body Measurements and Progress Photos
Instead of focusing solely on body fat percentages, use these more reliable tools:
- Circumference Measurements – Measure areas like the waist, hips, thighs, and arms to track fat loss or muscle gain.
- Progress Photos – Take front, side, and back photos under consistent lighting conditions to compare changes over time.
- Clothing Fit – Notice how your clothes fit; changes in waist size, muscle fullness, or overall comfort in clothing are great indicators of body recomposition.
These methods provide a visual and measurable way to see real progress without the inaccuracies of body fat testing devices.
4. Journaling and Habit Tracking
Reflecting on your journey helps solidify positive behaviors. Tracking daily habits such as water intake, step count, meal consistency, and stress management can reveal patterns that contribute to success.
Journaling about challenges, wins, and mindset shifts also helps reinforce long-term adherence to your goals. Writing down small victories, such as hitting a personal record in the gym or feeling stronger during a workout, can keep motivation high.
We’ve created a custom journal to help clients do all of this and more.
How to Use Multiple Data Points for Better Accuracy
To get a clear picture of your progress, combine multiple tracking methods. Here’s a simple framework:
- Weekly Weigh-Ins – Take a morning weight average from 5-7 days per week.
- Monthly Measurements and Progress Photos – Track circumferences and take pictures every 4-6 weeks.
- Daily Biofeedback Tracking – Rate energy, sleep, digestion, and stress on a scale of 1-5.
- Workout Log – Track strength and conditioning improvements every session.
- Journaling and Habit Tracking – Write reflections and monitor behaviors contributing to success.
By layering these different data points, you’ll gain a more accurate assessment of your fitness journey while avoiding misleading fluctuations from any single metric.
Final Thoughts: Measure What Matters
Measuring progress in fitness and nutrition goes beyond just the scale or body fat percentage. By focusing on multiple data points—biofeedback, performance, measurements, and habits—you gain a comprehensive view of your success.
Cody McBroom encourages taking a structured approach to tracking, saying, “The key to real progress isn’t in a single number, but in the trends and patterns that show sustainable change.”
For more expert coaching and fitness and nutrition strategies, check out the Tailored Coaching Method Blog and follow Cody McBroom on Instagram. Start measuring what truly matters and take control of your fitness journey today!
You can gain more expert fitness and nutrition guidance by subscribing to the Choose Hard Podcast on YouTube, Spotify or Apple! And to watch the video version of this article here, check out the content below:
